Procedure

Comedone Extraction

A provider clears blackheads and whiteheads with a small tool. The result is immediate and temporary — pores refill within weeks unless a daily treatment changes them.
Dr. Schwarz, MD · Board-certified dermatologistLast reviewed August 23, 2026
A double-ended stainless steel comedone extractor lying horizontally on a white background: a slim polished rod with a small open wire loop at each end.

Start here

Emptying a blackhead is satisfying and visible, which is why it gets misused — the pore refills within weeks unless something changes how it behaves, and only a retinoid does that. It works best as a head start: you begin adapalene or tretinoin, we clear the plugs already there, and the topical stops new ones forming. On its own it is a treadmill. I am firm about force, because pushing on a blackhead that will not come out with gentle pressure ruptures the pore and turns it into an inflamed spot, then a brown mark that lasts months.

— Dr. Schwarz, Board Certified Dermatologist

Key Facts

−
Also calledAcne surgery, manual extraction, comedo extraction, "pore clearing"
DowntimeRedness for a few hours to 2 days
SessionsAs needed. Often at the start of an acne plan, then occasionally
Typical costOften included in a dermatology visit; about $75 to $250 as a standalone or acne facial service in the US
Results timelineImmediate — the pore is emptied that day
PainPinching pressure. Blackheads are mild; whiteheads need a tiny nick and sting more
Skin tone safetySafe for all tones, but forced extraction leaves dark marks more easily on deeper skin tones

What It Is

−

A small metal loop, a fine sterile needle, or gloved fingers with cotton press the contents out of a clogged pore. Blackheads (open comedones) come out with pressure alone. Whiteheads (closed comedones) need a tiny opening made first. Sometimes called acne surgery, it removes what is in the pore and nothing else.

How It Works

−

A comedone is a plug of dead skin cells and oil in the pore. In a blackhead the plug is open to the air and darkens by oxidation — not dirt. Extraction pushes it out. Nothing changes about oil production or how fast the pore lining sheds cells, so it refills on the same schedule, over several weeks to a couple of months.

Skin is about two millimetres thick on the face. How deep a treatment reaches decides what it can change, and whether it treats all of the skin or scattered columns of it decides how long you take to heal.

How it works
Compare
Skin basics
EPIDERMISDERMISFAT0.05 mm — pigment0.5 mm — texture + pores1.0 mm — collagen1.5 mm — deep dermisPEELNEEDLINGNON-ABLATIVE LASERABLATIVE LASERSTAYS IN THE TOP LAYER

This works in the epidermis, the top layer, only about a tenth of a millimetre thick. That is the right depth for surface pigment, flaking and rough texture, and it is why nothing at this depth can change a scar or a wrinkle that is set in the layer below.

A peel or a scrub takes the skin off evenly from the surface down. Everything above the line goes and nothing below it is touched, which is why peels suit surface pigment and rough texture, and why the whole face flakes for a few days after.

Needles make hundreds of separate channels and leave the skin between them untouched. That untouched skin is what heals the rest, so recovery is quick — but a needle only injures the skin to start repair. It removes nothing.

The light passes through the surface and heats a column underneath it. The surface stays whole, so you leave red rather than raw — and it takes a course of sessions rather than one.

The laser removes columns of skin outright: the white gaps here are tissue that is gone, and new skin grows in from the sides. The strongest of the four, and the longest to heal.

The outer layer, and the only one anything in a jar reaches. It renews itself constantly: a cell made at the bottom takes about a month to reach the surface and flake off. Most of what a skincare product does, it does here.

The living layer underneath, holding the blood vessels, the nerves and the collagen. It is where lasting change happens and it is hard to reach: most of what is sold for the skin never gets this far.

What It Treats

−
Milia
Strong evidence
The definitive treatment, and the only thing that actually empties a milium. The roof is nicked with a sterile blade or needle and light pressure lifts the keratin pearl out whole, in about ten seconds a bump. The one that is removed does not come back in that spot. Done once, properly, it heals in a few days; repeated digging at the same place is what leaves marks.

Not the Best For

−
Close-up of a cheek with inflamed acne. Raised pink-red bumps, a few with yellow-white heads, sit in a patch of redness, and the skin between them is dry and flaking.
Acne
Limited evidence
Clears blackheads that are already there, quickly and visibly. It does not stop new ones forming, so it is an add-on to a retinoid rather than a substitute for one.
Two skin close-ups side by side, labeled Whitehead (Closed Comedone) and Blackhead (Open Comedone)
New blackheads forming
Doesn't work
Extraction empties the pores you have today. It does nothing to the ones filling up underneath, so they come back within weeks unless something is treating the skin daily.
Close-up of pink raised bumps, some with small white tips, on flaking skin
Deep, painful cysts
Makes it worse
A cyst is not a surface plug. Pressing on one pushes the inflammation deeper and raises the chance of a scar.
Close-up of the cheek, nose and mouth of an adult with light skin, turned three-quarters away from the camera against a pale blue background. The surface of the cheek is uneven, dimpled with shallow depressions and small pits that catch the light. There are no active spots — the change here is in the texture of the skin rather than its color.
Acne scars
Doesn't work
Clearing plugs does not change the shape of skin that is already scarred.

Pros and Cons

−
Pros
  • Immediate Visible in the mirror before you leave.
  • Helps topicals work Clear the old plugs and a retinoid only fights new ones.
  • Prevents some inflammation A plug left in place can rupture into a painful spot.
Cons
  • Entirely temporary Pores refill in 4 to 8 weeks without daily treatment.
  • Marks if forced Aggressive extraction leaves brown marks or small scars.
  • Thin evidence Guidelines call it a helpful add-on, not a treatment.
  • Cost adds up As a repeated facial service, expensive for what it does.

How to Prepare

−
A few weeks beforeA few days beforeOn the day
Prep products
A few weeks before
Some providers ask for a retinoid or salicylic acid first, which loosens plugs and makes extraction easier.
Do not pick
A few days before
No picking or squeezing at home. Inflamed spots cannot be extracted.
Clean face
On the day
Come without makeup if you can.

What Happens

−
ArrivingThe treatmentLeaving
Arriving
Skin is cleaned and the provider decides which spots can be extracted. Inflamed cysts are left alone or injected instead. No numbing, though numbing cream is occasional for extensive work. Some offices soften plugs first with warm steam or salicylic acid. Your provider will ask about these things.
The treatment
The provider presses around the pore with a metal loop or two swabs, opening whiteheads first with a tiny sterile needle. You feel firm pinching at each spot. A full face takes 10 to 30 minutes. Blackheads are pressure more than pain; whiteheads and deeper plugs sting when opened, and a long run is tiring rather than sharp. A painful spot is not forced.
Leaving
Red, blotchy skin with pink rings where spots were, sometimes pinpoint scabs. More visible on the day than people expect.

Recovery

−
Hours 2 to 6Days 1 to 2Days 3 to 7
Hours 2 to 6
Redness and small raised rings, sometimes into the next day, with occasional pinpoint scabs where a whitehead was opened.
Days 1 to 2
Redness mostly gone. Scabs are small, dry, and fall off in a few days — do not pick them. An extracted pore occasionally turns into a red bump.
Days 3 to 7
Skin looks normal. A few spots may leave a temporary brown mark, more likely on deeper skin tones, fading over weeks.

Aftercare

−
12 to 24 hours24 hoursEvery day
Makeup
12 to 24 hours
Wait 12 to 24 hours.
Actives and exercise
24 hours
Skip retinoids and acids for a day. Exercise is fine — rinse sweat off promptly.
Sun
Every day
Sunscreen daily. Sun on freshly extracted spots makes brown marks more likely.

Risks

−

Extraction is low-risk done gently, higher-risk when forced.

A brown mark that persists
Post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation is more common and slower to fade on deeper skin tones. Treat it early.
Inflamed spots after every session
The technique is too forceful, or these are not simple comedones.

Combining Treatments

−
Same day
Topical retinoid
This is what prevents new comedones, so it continues.
Same day
BP and salicylic acid
Both pair naturally with extraction and continue.
Same day
Light peel or steam
Extraction is often done straight after, when plugs release easily.
Same day
Cortisone injection
Same visit, for inflamed cysts.
Wait 2 weeks
Laser or microneedling
Wait about 2 weeks before extracting the same area.
Don’t combine
Peeling or irritated skin
No extraction on peeling or irritated skin.

Insurance Coverage

−

Insurance sometimes covers it when billed as acne surgery at a medical dermatology visit. It depends on your plan, and never applies to a spa facial.

Ask Your Doctor

−
If your acne is inflamed or cystic
Red, painful, deep spots cannot be extracted; pressure ruptures them further.
If you have an active skin infection
Cold sores, impetigo, or infected spots in the area.
If you are on or just off isotretinoin
Skin is fragile and tears easily. Most providers wait until well into or after the course.
If you scar with keloids
Repeated trauma to a pore is a poor idea.
If you have a deeper skin tone
The risk is a dark mark rather than a scar. Keep it gentle, limited in one sitting, and pair it with sunscreen and a pigment cream.
If you bruise easily
Or take a blood thinner. Expect more bruising; the provider should work lightly.
If your skin is very oily and congested
A very long session causes more inflammation. Split it across visits.
If you have rosacea or sensitive skin
Skin flushes and stays red much longer.

At-Home Versions

−
Topical retinoid (adapalene 0.1%, or prescription tretinoin)
Good alternative
Not an extraction, but the only thing that reliably stops comedones forming. This does more over 12 weeks than any number of extractions.
Comedone extractor loop
Okay alternative
The same tool, sold cheaply. It works on obvious blackheads with light pressure. Most people use too much force, and that is the whole risk.
Pore strips
Okay alternative
They pull off the very top of surface plugs. Cosmetic, short-lived, and irritating.
Suction pore vacuums
Okay alternative
Little useful effect on real plugs, and they cause bruising and broken vessels at higher settings.

How It Compares

−
Topical retinoid
Different job
The only thing that stops comedones forming. Extraction clears what is already there; a retinoid decides whether it comes back, which is why the two are usually started together.
Salicylic acid peel
Different job
Loosens plugs across the whole face rather than clearing them one at a time. Often done immediately before extraction rather than instead of it.
Microdermabrasion and facials
Worse
Remove some shallow plugs and surface debris. Gentler, less complete, and marketed far harder than the evidence supports.
Hydrafacial-style treatments
Worse
A facial that includes light suction extraction. More comfortable and more expensive, with less clearing of stubborn plugs than a provider working by hand.

Finding a Provider

+

Dermatologists, their physician assistants and nurse practitioners, and licensed estheticians all do extractions. Scope varies by state, and in most places only medical providers should open lesions with a lancet. Ask how they decide when to stop pushing on a spot. Red flags: extracting inflamed cysts, force that bruises deeply, full-face extractions every two weeks with no home plan, claims that this shrinks pores permanently.

Questions Patients Ask

+

Does extraction get rid of blackheads for good?

No. It empties the pore that day. It refills over 4 to 8 weeks unless a daily retinoid changes how the pore behaves.

Is it better than doing it myself?

Mostly yes — technique and restraint. A provider uses sterile tools, opens closed spots properly, and stops when a spot resists. Home squeezing causes most brown marks and small scars.

Can they extract a cyst?

No. Deep, red, painful lumps have no opening to press through, and forcing one makes it worse. A cortisone injection is the answer.

Does it make pores smaller?

Only in appearance, and briefly. An empty pore looks smaller; pore size does not change.

Does it hurt?

Blackheads feel like firm pinching. Whiteheads sting for a second when opened. Uncomfortable rather than painful.

References

+