Neutrogena Ultra Gentle Hydrating Facial Cleanser: Dermatologist Review

Neutrogena Ultra Gentle Hydrating Facial Cleanser is a creamy, low-lather wash for dry and sensitive skin, fragrance free, about $8 to $11 at drugstores. No acid, no niacinamide, no ceramides. Neutrogena sells several Ultra Gentle products in near-identical bottles, so read the label, not the shelf tag.

The list is ten ingredients long. Polyglyceryl-10 laurate does the cleaning — a non-ionic surfactant, meaning no electrical charge, which makes it far less aggressive on skin proteins than a sulfate. Glycerin and cetearyl alcohol give it the creamy body. That is the whole formula.

It is a thin, white, creamy lotion that barely foams.

It spreads over wet skin easily and rinses off without a film. Skin feels soft rather than squeaky, not tight. If you judge a cleanser by lather, this will feel like it is doing nothing.

Fragrance free, almost no smell. A flip cap bottle, and one lasts a long time because you need very little.

Balm

A solid that melts into an oil in the warmth of your hands.

Melts sunscreen and makeup and will not drip, which makes it easy to travel with. It needs a real rinse, with a cloth or a second wash, or it stays on the skin.

‹ HeavierLighter ›

Oil

Pure oil, no water. Goes on dry skin and lifts oil off with oil.

The best thing on this scale for sunscreen and makeup, and it does not strip. Some oils clog pores on acne-prone skin, and it needs a rinse or a second wash or it sits there.

‹ HeavierLighter ›

→

Oil-to-Foam

Pours as an oil, then turns milky and foams the moment water hits it.

Takes off sunscreen like an oil but rinses away completely, so one step does both. The lather at the end means it is not as gentle as a plain oil.

‹ HeavierLighter ›

Cream · this one

Thick and white, like a light lotion. Barely lathers at all.

Comfortable on dry, sensitive or older skin, and it rinses without the tight feeling. It can leave a slick film, and it will not take off a heavy sunscreen by itself.

‹ HeavierLighter ›

→

Cream-to-Foam

Starts as a cream, turns to a soft foam under water.

A cushioned start with a rinse-clean finish, which suits normal or combination skin. It does lather, so it takes more oil off than a plain cream.

‹ HeavierLighter ›

Gel

Clear and jelly-like. Spreads thin and rinses off fast.

Feels fresh on oily skin. Many gels carry salicylic acid or another acid, which can sting if your skin is already sore.

‹ HeavierLighter ›

→

Gel-to-Foam

Comes out as a gel, then whips into a lather once you add water.

A middle option if a plain gel feels too thin. The lather is what does the cleaning, so it can still leave dry skin tight.

‹ HeavierLighter ›

Foaming

Arrives as a lather, from a pump head or worked up in your hands. Mostly air.

Gives the fresh, squeaky finish a lot of people like on oily skin. That squeak is your own oil coming off too, so it suits dry or sore skin badly.

‹ HeavierLighter ›

Micellar Water
photo to come

Micellar Water

Water carrying tiny cleansing droplets called micelles. Swiped on with a cotton pad.

Handy when you cannot get to a sink. It leaves a film if you skip the rinse, and it will not shift sunscreen on its own.

‹ HeavierLighter ›

Texture tells you how a wash feels. This tells you how much of your own oil it takes with it. The two do not line up — two foaming cleansers can sit three rungs apart.

Bar soap

The bar at your sink or in the shower.

Cuts grease fast. Its high pH swells the surface, so skin feels tight.

‹ Strips moreStrips less ›

Sulfates and sulfonates

What makes a wash foam up thick and fast.

Strips oil quickly. Too much for dry or sore skin.

‹ Strips moreStrips less ›

Mild anionics

Cousins of the sulfates, built to be less harsh.

Still lathers, without the tight feel after. Can be a lot for eczema.

‹ Strips moreStrips less ›

Amphoterics

Added to soften a harsher detergent and build foam.

Rarely cleans on its own. A common cause of skincare allergy.

‹ Strips moreStrips less ›

Amino-acid surfactants

Made from the same building blocks as your skin's protein.

Foams at a pH close to skin's own, so it rarely stings. Costs more.

‹ Strips moreStrips less ›

NonionicsIn this cleanser

Carry no charge, so they barely stick to skin protein.

The mildest that still foams. Weak lather can feel like it is not working.

‹ Strips moreStrips less ›

No surfactant

No detergent. Oil dissolves the oil on your face.

Takes the least off. Needs a cloth or second wash to remove.

‹ Strips moreStrips less ›

Every cleanser works the same way. A surfactant has one end that likes water and one that likes oil, so it surrounds the grease on your face and lets water carry it off. What separates a harsh wash from a mild one is what else it takes. Sulfates carry a negative charge that binds to skin proteins and makes them swell — the tight, stinging feeling — and a strong wash can leave the barrier worse than it found it.

This one uses a non-ionic surfactant, polyglyceryl-10 laurate, with no charge to bind with. It lifts oil and leaves proteins and most lipids where they are.

The cost of that mildness is cleaning power — it will not take water-resistant sunscreen off in one pass. And hydrating is a stretch. A cleanser sits on your face for a minute and goes down the drain. Not stripping you is worth a lot; adding water is the moisturizer's job.

This is how many ingredients are on the label. The more a product contains, the more chances one of them bothers you. That matters most if you have sensitive skin, eczema, or a known allergy. If your skin tolerates most things, a long list is not a problem by itself.

The names in the line are confusing: Neutrogena sells several "Ultra Gentle" cleansers — hydrating, foaming, daily — with near-identical packaging and different formulas. Read the bottle, not the shelf tag.

It does not remove sunscreen well: it is low-surfactant, so it struggles with sunscreen. If you wear SPF daily, use something with more cleaning power at night, or an oil-based cleanser.

Hydrating oversells what it does: it does not strip, which is not the same as adding hydration. A cleanser is on your face for a minute and goes down the drain. No cleanser meaningfully moisturizes you.

It has no ceramides or niacinamide: unlike CeraVe's and La Roche-Posay's equivalents at a similar price.

Neutrogena Ultra Gentle Hydrating Facial Cleanser costs $1.59 per ounce. That is cheaper than 10 of the other 16 cleansers priced on Dermapedia, which run from $0.59 to $3.50 per ounce.

A cleanser goes down the drain, so you get through it far faster than a leave-on product the same size. Bottle size matters more than the per-ounce figure.

Options with ceramides, or more cleansing power at night. Mild and thorough pull against each other.

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Hydrating Gentle Cleanser

Fragrance-free and creamy, with the ceramide and niacinamide this one skips. Costs more, bigger bottle.

We recommend more

Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser

Also fragrance-free and mild, with no dyes or lanolin, and it still cleans properly. It carries the National Eczema Association seal.

We recommend more

Aveeno Calm + Restore Nourishing Oat Face Cleanser

Milder still, with colloidal oatmeal, an FDA-recognized skin protectant. It removes no sunscreen at all, and it contains feverfew, a ragweed relative.

We recommend less