STUDY

Microneedling has better proof than microdermabrasion for acne scars

“Evidence-based management of cutaneous scarring in dermatology part 2: atrophic acne scarring.” Kim EY et al. Archives of Dermatological Research. December 2023

Kim EY et al. · Archives of Dermatological Research · December 2023

Narrative review
The finding

A review of indented acne scars found stronger evidence for microneedling than for microdermabrasion across the literature it assessed.

Type of study

Narrative review

Evidence review of acne scar procedures. The authors discussed the available evidence for several treatments rather than assigning patients to treatments.
At a glance

Who was studied and for how long

Paper type
Review
No new participants
Condition
Indented acne scars
Icepick, boxcar and rolling scars
Scope
Multiple procedures
Including microneedling and microdermabrasion
What they did

How the study worked

Review scar typesThe paper describes the main patterns of indented scarring.
Review treatmentsIt discusses lasers, peels, fillers, microneedling and other procedures.
Assess evidenceThe authors describe which approaches have stronger support.
What they found

The results

Stronger evidence

The authors identified stronger evidence for several lasers, chemical peels, fillers, microneedling and PRP as an add-on.

Less robust evidence

They identified lower-quality evidence for microdermabrasion, subcision and fat grafting.

A larger or stronger evidence base does not show how much better one procedure would perform in the same patients.
How much to trust it

Strengths and limits

Strengths

  • Covers multiple procedures
  • Distinguishes stronger and weaker evidence
  • Recognizes that scar type matters

Limits

  • No randomized comparison in this paper
  • No single protocol for procedures
  • The review does not quantify the difference between microneedling and microdermabrasion
Limited confidence for direct comparisons. This review summarizes the evidence base but does not estimate a head-to-head effect.
What it means for you

The takeaway

Evidence favors studying microneedling

The review found more support for microneedling for indented scars. It did not measure how the two procedures compare directly.

Pages that cite this study

Read more on Dermapedia

Terms in this study

Words worth knowing

Atrophic scars

Indented scars that sit below the surrounding skin.

Original source

Kim EY, Wong JH, Hussain A, Khachemoune A. Evidence-based management of cutaneous scarring in dermatology part 2: atrophic acne scarring.. Arch Dermatol Res. 2023;316(1):19.

PMID 38059974