STUDY

Hydroquinone faded melasma more than vitamin C but caused more side effects

“A double-blind randomized trial of 5% ascorbic acid vs. 4% hydroquinone in melasma.” Espinal-Perez LE et al. International Journal of Dermatology. August 2004

Espinal-Perez LE et al. · International Journal of Dermatology · August 2004

Randomized split-face trialMelasmaHydroquinoneVitamin C
The finding

In a small 16-week trial of 16 women with melasma, hydroquinone 4% got better self-rated results than vitamin C 5% (93% vs 62.5%), but caused far more side effects. Skin-color measurements showed no clear difference.

Type of study

Where this study sits on the evidence spectrum

Some kinds of studies are much more reliable than others. Studies further right do more to rule out chance and bias.

Weaker evidenceStronger evidence
Lab or animal studyCase reportCase seriesCohort studyRandomized trialMeta-analysis
Randomized and double-blind, with a split-face design. Each woman used one cream on one side of her face and the other cream on the other side. Chance decided which side got which, and a different clinician did the randomizing. Comparing sides on the same face helps rule out differences between people.
At a glance

Who was studied and for how long

People
16
All women
Length
16 weeks
Cream applied at night
Condition
Melasma
Dark patches on the face
Compared
5% vitamin C vs 4% hydroquinone
One cream per side of the face
Sunscreen
Daily
Used by everyone
What they did

How the study worked

16 womenmelasmaRANDOMSPLIT5% vitaminC creamOne side of faceevery night4% hydroquinonecreamOther side of faceevery nightMEASURED ATWeek 16by color device, photos, self-rating16 womenmelasmaRANDOMSPLIT5% vitamin C creamOne side of face · every night4% hydroquinone creamOther side of face · every nightMEASURED ATWeek 16by color device, photos, self-rating
1. Split face16 women with melasma used vitamin C cream on one side of the face and hydroquinone cream on the other.
2. Same routineCreams were applied at night for 16 weeks, with daily sunscreen.
3. MeasuredSkin color was measured with a device and photos, and each woman rated her own improvement.
What they found

The results

5% vitamin C cream4% hydroquinone cream

Good or excellent improvement

Women's own rating of results

Vitamin C
62.5%
Hydroquinone
93%
Difference unlikely to be chance (p < 0.05)

People with side effects

Share of women with any side effect (11 of 16 vs 1 of 16)

Vitamin C
6.2%
Hydroquinone
68.7%
Women rated hydroquinone better. But the color-measuring device found no clear difference between the two creams. Hydroquinone caused side effects in about 7 of 10 women, versus about 1 in 16 for vitamin C. With only 16 women, the results should be treated as an early signal.
How much to trust it

Strengths and limits

Strengths

  • Split-face design compares both creams in the same person
  • Used color measurements and photos, not just opinions
  • Randomized

Limits

  • Very small: only 16 women
  • Self-rated results favored hydroquinone, but color readings did not show a clear gap
  • Only 16 weeks
  • Older study: 2004
Low confidence. A small trial. It is a useful early look, but larger studies are needed.
What it means for you

The takeaway

Early evidence

In this small trial, hydroquinone looked better to the women using it, but vitamin C had far fewer side effects and the color measurements were close.

Vitamin C may be a gentler option for people who cannot use hydroquinone. Your dermatologist can help you choose.

Pages that cite this study

Read more on Dermapedia

Terms in this study

Words worth knowing

Melasma

Brown or gray patches on the face, often triggered by sun and hormones.

Split-face trial

Each person tests two treatments, one on each side of the face.

Colorimetry

Measuring skin color with a device instead of by eye.

p-value

A measure of how likely a difference this size would show up by chance alone. Below 0.05 is the usual cutoff for "probably real."

Original source

Espinal-Perez LE, Moncada B, Castanedo-Cazares JP. A double-blind randomized trial of 5% ascorbic acid vs. 4% hydroquinone in melasma. Int J Dermatol. 2004;43(8):604–607.

PMID 15304189