Niacinamide gel worked about as well as an antibiotic gel for acne
“Topical nicotinamide compared with clindamycin gel in the treatment of inflammatory acne vulgaris.” Shalita AR et al. International Journal of Dermatology. June 1995
Shalita AR et al. · International Journal of Dermatology · June 1995
In an 8-week trial of 76 people with moderate acne, 4% niacinamide gel worked about as well as 1% clindamycin gel, a prescription antibiotic.
Type of study
Where this study sits on the evidence spectrum
Some kinds of studies are much more reliable than others. Studies further right do more to rule out chance and bias.
Weaker evidenceStronger evidence
Lab or animal studyCase reportCase seriesCohort studyRandomized trialMeta-analysis
R
Randomized and double-blind. A coin-flip process decided who got which gel, and neither the patients nor the doctors knew which one they had. That keeps expectations from skewing the results.
At a glance
Who was studied and for how long
People
76
38 in each group
Length
8 weeks
Checked at weeks 4 and 8
Condition
Moderate acne
Inflammatory: red bumps and pustules
Compared
4% vs 1%
Niacinamide gel vs clindamycin gel
How often
Twice daily
Both groups
Where
US, multicenter
More than one clinic
What they did
How the study worked
1. Split at random76 people with moderate acne were randomly put in one of two equal groups.
2. Same routineEach group applied its gel twice a day for 8 weeks. Nobody knew which gel they had.
3. Three measuresDoctors rated overall improvement, counted red bumps and pustules, and scored severity.
What they found
The results
4% niacinamide1% clindamycin
People who improved
Doctor's overall rating of the acne
Niacinamide
82%
Clindamycin
68%
Difference could be chance (p = 0.19)
Fewer red bumps and pustules
Drop in inflamed acne spots from the start
Niacinamide
−60%
Clindamycin
−43%
Difference could be chance (p = 0.168)
Less severe acne
Drop in acne severity score from the start
Niacinamide
−52%
Clindamycin
−38%
Difference could be chance (p = 0.161)
Niacinamide's numbers were higher, but the gap was small enough that it could be chance. So the fair conclusion is that the two gels worked about equally well, not that niacinamide was better.
How much to trust it
Strengths and limits
Strengths
Randomized and double-blind, the strongest design for a single study
Compared against a proven prescription, not just a plain gel
Run at more than one clinic
Limits
Small: 76 people
Short: 8 weeks, so it can't show long-term results
No placebo group, so it can't show how much either gel beat doing nothing
Only moderate inflamed acne; not blackheads or severe acne
Moderate confidence. A well-designed trial, but one small, short study. Larger trials would make this stronger.
What it means for you
The takeaway
Use niacinamide
For mild to moderate red acne, use 4% niacinamide gel first if you want to avoid a topical antibiotic. In this trial it matched clindamycin, and because it is not an antibiotic it doesn't add to antibiotic resistance.
If you are already on clindamycin and it's working, keep using it. Talk to your dermatologist before you switch.
Neither the people in the study nor the doctors measuring results knew who got which treatment. This keeps hopes and expectations from coloring the results.
p-value
A measure of how likely a difference this size would show up by chance alone. Below 0.05 is the usual cutoff for "probably real." These results were 0.16 to 0.19, so the differences between the gels could be chance.
Inflammatory acne
The red, swollen kind of acne: papules (red bumps) and pustules (bumps with a white or yellow center). Different from blackheads and whiteheads.
Nicotinamide
Another name for niacinamide, a form of vitamin B3. Older studies often use this name.
Original source
Shalita AR, Smith JG, Parish LC, Sofman MS, Chalker DK. Topical nicotinamide compared with clindamycin gel in the treatment of inflammatory acne vulgaris. Int J Dermatol. 1995;34(6):434–437.