STUDY

Doctors rated the CO₂ laser higher; the picosecond laser had fewer side effects

“Comparison of the fractionated Nd: YAG 1064-nm picosecond laser with holographic optics and the fractional CO2 laser in atrophic acne scar treatment: a prospective, randomized, split-face study.” Yuan Y et al. International journal of dermatology. January 2025

Yuan Y et al. · International journal of dermatology · January 2025

Randomized split-face trial
The finding

The scar severity score showed no clear difference, while doctors rated improvement higher with CO₂ and the picosecond laser caused fewer side effects.

Type of study

Where this study sits on the evidence spectrum

Some kinds of studies are much more reliable than others. Studies further right do more to rule out chance and bias.

Weaker evidenceStronger evidence
Lab or animal studyCase reportCase seriesCohort studyRandomized trialMeta-analysis
Randomized split-face trial. Each participant received one laser on each side of the face, with the sides assigned at random.
At a glance

Who was studied and for how long

Compared
Two lasers
Fractional CO₂ and fractional picosecond Nd:YAG
Sessions
Three
Two months apart
Follow-up
3 months
After the final session
Condition
Atrophic acne scars
Indented scars
What they did

How the study worked

Study participantsindented acne scarsRANDOMSPLITFractional CO₂One face side3 sessionsPicosecond laserOther face side3 sessionsMEASURED ATMonth 3after final sessionStudy participantsindented acne scarsRANDOMSPLITFractional CO₂One face side · 3 sessionsPicosecond laserOther face side · 3 sessionsMEASURED ATMonth 3after final session
Assign face sidesEach person received a different laser on each side.
Treat in a seriesThe study used a fractional 1064 nm picosecond laser with holographic optics and a fractional CO₂ laser.
Assess both sidesDoctors scored scars and improvement, and the study tracked patients’ ratings and side effects.
What they found

The results

Acne scar severity

The average ECCA severity score after treatment did not differ clearly between the two laser treatments.

No clear difference (p = 0.209)

Doctors’ overall improvement ratings

On a separate four-point assessment, doctors rated the fractional CO₂ side as more improved.

p = 0.001

Side effects

The picosecond laser side had fewer reported side effects.

p < 0.001
The scar severity score and the doctors’ improvement ratings measured different things. The abstract reports the direction and statistical tests for these findings but gives no arm-level effect sizes.
Who paid for it

Funding and conflicts of interest

The Nanjing Incubation Program for National Clinical Research Center supported the study. The authors declared no conflicts of interest.

How much to trust it

Strengths and limits

Strengths

  • Randomized comparison on opposite sides of the same face
  • Measured outcomes after a series of treatments
  • Recorded both clinician and patient assessments

Limits

  • The abstract does not state the number analyzed or show arm-level effect sizes
  • Follow-up ended three months after the last treatment
  • The study tested specific laser configurations
Moderate confidence. Randomizing opposite sides of each face helps control for differences between people. The results varied by outcome.
What it means for you

The takeaway

Improvement and recovery tradeoffs

The physician improvement rating favored CO₂, while the picosecond side had fewer adverse effects. The overall scar severity score showed no clear difference.

Pages that cite this study

Read more on Dermapedia

Terms in this study

Words worth knowing

Atrophic scars

Indented scars that sit below the surrounding skin.

ECCA

A clinician-rated scale for acne scar severity.

Original source

Yuan Y, He Y, Fang J, Zhang M, Wu Q. Comparison of the fractionated Nd: YAG 1064-nm picosecond laser with holographic optics and the fractional CO2 laser in atrophic acne scar treatment: a prospective, randomized, split-face study.. Int J Dermatol. 2025;64(1):85–91.

PMID 38924534