Aloe Vera
← All comparisons
Dermapedia / Compare
Aloe Vera Gel vs Aloe Vera Lotion
Aloe vera gel is mostly water and aloe. It sinks in fast, cools on contact, then evaporates and leaves nothing behind. Aloe vera lotion adds oils and emollients. Those stay on the skin and hold water in. Gel for immediate cooling after sun or heat. Lotion for skin that is genuinely dry.
At a glance
| The difference | Aloe Vera | Aloe vera lotion |
|---|---|---|
| What is in it | Water, aloe and a thickener | Aloe plus oils and emollients |
| How it feels going on | Cold and wet, then gone | Creamy, and it stays |
| What it is good for | Heat, sunburn and itch | Dry, rough, flaky skin |
| Cost | Cheap | Cheap |
Aloe vera lotion
Aloe plus oils and emollients The same aloe, mixed into a base of oils, butters or glycerin, with a bit of wax to hold it together.
Side by side
The differences that matter
What is in it
Aloe Vera
Water, aloe and a thickener
The gel from inside the leaf, thickened so it spreads. Often a preservative and, in many drugstore versions, alcohol and green dye.
Aloe vera lotion
Aloe plus oils and emollients
The same aloe, mixed into a base of oils, butters or glycerin, with a bit of wax to hold it together.
How it works, illustrated
Aloe Vera
How it feels going on
Aloe Vera
Cold and wet, then gone
It is noticeably cool, sits on top for a minute, then dries down. Some brands leave a slight sticky film.
Aloe vera lotion
Creamy, and it stays
Absorbs more slowly and leaves the skin feeling soft rather than tight.
What it is good for
Aloe Vera
Heat, sunburn and itch
The cooling is real and immediate. It suits hot, stinging skin, and it is comfortable on skin that hurts to touch.
Aloe vera lotion
Dry, rough, flaky skin
Elbows, shins, hands and anywhere that gets tight after washing. It is a day-to-day moisturizer.
What it will not do
Aloe Vera
It does not seal moisture in
There is almost no oil in it, so water evaporates straight back out. On dry skin, gel alone can leave you drier than before.
Aloe vera lotion
It does not cool you down
A lotion warms to skin temperature quickly. On a sunburn it feels heavy rather than soothing.
Forms and types
Aloe Vera
Standalone gel
A tub or bottle of clear or dyed gel. Cooling, and the form most people mean.
1 / 4→
After-sun lotion
Aloe in a light moisturizing base, so it soothes and rehydrates at once.
←2 / 4→
Moisturizer
Aloe partway down the list of an ordinary cream. Pleasant, and not the active part.
←3 / 4→
Sheet mask
A soaked layer held against the skin. A comfortable top-up, not a routine.
←4 / 4
Conditions treated
Aloe Vera
Sunburn
Cooling and pleasant on a burn, and it is what most people reach for first. The trial evidence that it does anything beyond that is thin. Keep it in the fridge if you like it, choose a plain gel without added fragrance or alcohol, and do not expect it to shorten anything. It is comfort, not treatment.
Related topic illustrations
Aloe Vera
Petrolatum
Strong evidence. Far better at holding water in and at protecting damaged skin. It is greasy and unpleasant on a hot, burned face, which is where aloe wins on feel.
1 / 4→
Glycerin
Strong evidence. A more reliable humectant, and in nearly every moisturizer already. It does not have the immediate cooling effect.
←2 / 4→
Colloidal oatmeal
Moderate evidence. Better human evidence for itch and irritated skin, and an approved skin protectant. Thicker and messier to apply.
←3 / 4→
Hydrocortisone 1%
Strong evidence for inflammation and itch, available without a prescription. It is a medicine with limits on where and how long it can be used, which aloe does not have.
←4 / 4
How long the effect lasts
Aloe Vera
Minutes to an hour
The cooling fades as it dries. Reapply as often as you like.
Aloe vera lotion
Hours
The oils stay on the surface and keep slowing water loss.
After a sunburn
Aloe Vera
The better first choice
Cool, light and easy to reapply on skin that is too sore to rub.
Aloe vera lotion
Better a few days later
Once the heat has gone and the skin starts to peel and tighten, a lotion is what stops the flaking.
The downside
Aloe Vera
Alcohol, dye and stickiness
Alcohol dries skin further, and the green colour is added, not natural. Cheap gels can also flake off in little rolls.
Aloe vera lotion
Fragrance and heaviness
Scented lotions are a common cause of irritation on already-inflamed skin. It also feels greasy in hot weather.
Cost
Aloe Vera
Cheap
A large bottle costs a few dollars.
Aloe vera lotion
Cheap
Priced like any other body lotion.
The easy answer
More photographs
Aloe Vera
Common questions
Questions Patients Ask
Is aloe vera gel or lotion better for sunburn?
Gel, in the first day or two. It is cool, light and easy to reapply on skin that is too sore to rub. Once the heat has gone and the skin starts to peel, switch to a lotion.
Can aloe vera gel make dry skin worse?
Yes. Gel is mostly water with almost no oil, so the water evaporates and can take some of the skin's own moisture with it. On dry skin, follow the gel with a moisturizer while the skin is still damp.
Does aloe vera gel moisturize?
Only briefly. It puts water on the skin but has nothing in it to seal that water in. A lotion contains oils and emollients that slow water escaping, which is what moisturizing actually means.
Why is my aloe gel bright green?
That is added dye. Aloe gel from the plant is close to clear. The colour is cosmetic, and it is one more ingredient that can irritate sensitive skin.
Should I avoid alcohol in aloe gel?
If your skin is dry, sensitive or sunburnt, yes. Alcohol makes the gel feel light and dry fast, and it also dries the skin and stings on broken skin. Alcohol-free versions are easy to find.
Can I use both?
Yes, and it is the best of both. Gel first for the cooling, then a lotion over the top to hold the moisture in.