DermaPedia
Menu
ConditionsIngredientsMedicationsProceduresReviewsCompare

Study breakdown

Niacinamide vs. Clindamycin for Acne

Quick answer

In a 1995 randomized, double-blind trial for moderate inflammatory acne, inflamed spot counts fell by about 60% with 4% niacinamide gel and 43% with 1% clindamycin gel after eight weeks. The difference was statistically inconclusive (p = 0.168). Only 49 of 76 enrolled participants were included in the efficacy analysis, and the trial did not establish that the gels were equally effective.

How the study was done

  1. 76 people enrolled Ages 13 to 35, with moderate inflammatory facial acne
  2. Assigned at random Both groups applied their gel to the face twice daily in a double-blind trial.
    • 4% niacinamide gel 38 people assigned
    • 1% clindamycin phosphate gel 38 people assigned
  3. Checked at weeks 4 and 8 Researchers counted inflamed spots, scored acne severity, and rated overall improvement.

Participants had at least 15 inflamed bumps or pustules on the face. The trial excluded people whose acne was mainly blackheads or whiteheads. Researchers used the starting exam as the baseline for the follow-up ratings.

What the researchers found

The table shows how much the average spot count and severity score fell from baseline. Neither between-group difference was statistically significant.

Outcome at eight weeks 4% niacinamide gel 1% clindamycin gel Between-group p-value
Reduction in inflamed spot count 59.5% 42.7% 0.168
Reduction in acne severity score 51.6% 38.4% 0.161

For the doctors’ overall assessment, the paper’s abstract gives 82% improvement with niacinamide, while the Results section gives 86% rated moderately or much better. Both report 68% for clindamycin and a between-group p-value of 0.19. The paper leaves the difference between the two niacinamide figures unexplained, and the overall assessment did not establish that the gels were equally effective.

Strengths and limitations

  • Direct comparison. The researchers assigned patients randomly and described the study as double-blind. They compared two active gels using the same application schedule.
  • Incomplete follow-up and exclusions. Seventeen participants did not finish. The efficacy analysis included 49 participants who had at least one follow-up assessment and no protocol violations, 21 in the niacinamide group and 28 in the clindamycin group.
  • Short follow-up and no inactive gel. The analyzed comparison covers eight weeks. The design leaves long-term effects and how much each gel helped compared with an inactive gel uncertain.
  • Narrow scope. This study tested a specific 4% niacinamide gel in moderate inflammatory facial acne. It leaves the effects of other niacinamide products and results in other types of acne uncertain. The paper reports partial funding from Genderm Corporation.

How this fits with acne treatment today

The study compared niacinamide with clindamycin used by itself. The American Academy of Dermatology recommends combining topical antibiotics with benzoyl peroxide to reduce antibiotic resistance. How niacinamide compares with that combination is a separate question.

Sources and further reading

Shalita AR, Smith JG, Parish LC, Sofman MS, Chalker DK. Topical nicotinamide compared with clindamycin gel in the treatment of inflammatory acne vulgaris. International Journal of Dermatology. 1995;34(6):434–437.

Read the full Niacinamide guide →

DermaPedia · The science-based skin encyclopedia.